Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Join the SuperFam
Our SuperFam members receive exclusive bonus content for $5.99/mo Join the SuperFam

Subscribe

Retired Detective Greg is called to a shooting at a home in a rural community. While investigators are still processing the scene, a stranger suddenly appears in the bushes with a gun to his head.

Greg brings the man in for questioning and quickly discovers something unsettling: he’s had several encounters with law enforcement in just the past week, and each time, he’s given officers a different name.

As Greg works to uncover the stranger’s real identity and determine what brought him to the scene of a shooting, the case becomes one he’ll never forget.

Guest Bio

Detective Greg retired with a total of 26 years across corrections, patrol, narcotics and violent crimes investigations. He was active on a joint agency SWAT team and then on his own agency’s Special Response Team for a total of 16 years and was also a Defensive Tactics and Firearm Instructor for his agency for almost all of his career.

Read Transcript

Yeardley: Hey, Small Town Fam. It’s Yeardley. Hey, how are you guys? I hope everything is really wonderfully well where you are. So, I was looking up some statistics the other day, and National Crime Data says that between 50% and 70% of solved homicides are committed by people who know their victim. That makes stranger on stranger murders much more unusual than I would have thought. Today’s episode fits that unusual description, and it comes to us from detective Greg, one of our favorite original guests. Greg is retired now, but when he was a detective, his police agency was in an extremely rural location. This scenario creates a whole set of challenges that are unique to small departments. For instance, your nearest backup could be 40 minutes away. That’s terrifying.

And it’s this kind of detail that made us want to launch Small Town Dicks in the first place to show that big time crime was happening in small towns everywhere, just less often than it does in big cities and also with many fewer resources. Meanwhile, the expectation that you’ll carry out a superb investigation is the same no matter where you are or what size your department is. This case is a shining example of that. Here is “Evil Walked In.”

Yeardley: Hi there, I’m Yeardley.

Dan: I’m Dan.

Dave: I’m Dave.

Paul: And I’m Paul.

Yeardley: And this is Small Town Dicks.

Dan: Dave and I are identical twins-

Dave: -And retired detectives from Small Town, USA.

Paul: And I’m a veteran cold case investigator who helped catch The Golden State Killer using a revolutionary DNA tool.

Dan: Between the three of us, we’ve investigated thousands of crimes, from petty theft to sexual assault, child abuse to murder.

Dave: Each case we cover is told by the detective who investigated it, offering a rare, personal account of how they solved the crime.

Paul: Names, places, and certain details have been changed to protect the privacy of victims and their families.

Dan: And although we’re aware that some of our listeners may be familiar with these cases, we ask you to please join us in continuing to protect the true identities of those involved-

Dave: -out of respect for what they’ve been through.

[unison]: Thank you.

[Small Town Dicks theme]

Yeardley: Today on Small Town Dicks. My friends, how are you? I’m so excited. I have Detective Dan.

Dan: Hey there.

Yeardley: Hey there. I have Detective Dave.

Dave: Hello there.

Yeardley: Hello, you. I have the one and only Paul Holes.

Paul: Hey, hey.

Yeardley: Hey, hey, PH and Small Town Fam. This is really, really a fun day. We have one of our OGs sitting at the table with us today. We have Detective Greg. Hi, Greg.

Greg: Hello. Thanks for having me back.

Yeardley: It’s so great to see you. For old and new listeners alike, Greg gave us an episode in Season 4 way back in the day called Accelerant. It’s excellent. If you haven’t heard it or it’s been a minute, you should go back and listen. Then he came back and gave us The Ginger Beard Man in Season 10. Greg, you’re retired now.

Greg: I am.

Yeardley: Congratulations.

Greg: Thank you.

Yeardley: Give us a little thumbnail because I remember when we first sat down with you, you had such a tiny department because you were quite rural and you could be the only guy patrolling, I don’t know, 50,000 square miles. It was insane. [Greg laughs] So, give us a little-

Dan: Basically Alaska.

Yeardley: Yeah, basically you were the only guy.

[laughter]

So, tell us a little bit about that.

Greg: Yeah, I work for a county agency and our county is 5,200 square miles. Most of that is rural forest land. There is a few major cities in there. Actually, there’s only two, and they’re right next door to each other. But they each have their own police departments. We contract out two smaller communities, cities in the county, but for the most part it goes quite a ways. And we field most shifts with just three deputies. Sometimes, we’ll get lucky and have a fourth on. And it doesn’t take long at all for all of them to be tied up on something. And it’s usually very far apart from each other.

Yeardley: Yeah, insane. I remember, I think it was “Accelerant,” the first case you gave us. If you needed cover, it could take 45 minutes to an hour for somebody to come and join you. And as we always say, five minutes can feel like a lifetime if you’re in trouble.

Greg: Absolutely. It’s quite a wait. Fortunately, we have some help from the state police that have their troopers out and about also, but also not many. And they could be coming from who knows where at the same time. Because they’re primarily responsible for patrolling actual state highways and we have a lot of rural roads, county roads, gravel roads, forest roads, wherever the calls take us. And can be confusing and hard to get to.

Yeardley: Right. And probably not very well marked.

Greg: No.

Yeardley: Oh my God. I’m glad you made it out safely. Well, let’s get to the business at hand, shall we?

Greg: All right.

Yeardley: Greg, please tell us how this case came to you.

Greg: This one came to me just as I came into service early in the morning, like 7 o’clock in the morning. So, I turn on the radio and just wait a minute just to see, make sure you’re not stepping over somebody’s traffic stop or something else. And also, for just this reason, I heard the channel marker tone on the radio.

Yeardley: What is that?

Dave: So, you turn the radio on and it lets everyone know something big is happening. Keep off the radio.

Yeardley: I see.

Greg: As I’m driving towards the office, my detective sergeant gave me a phone call. He said there was a shooting out in the small pass through community on one of the highways, probably about 40 minutes from where I came in service. One person had been transported by ambulance with a gunshot wound to the head and that there was likely a deceased person inside. So, eventually I get there and I find out that there was indeed a female who was found dead in the house. A male subject had been shot in the head. He had been transported and was still alive at that time. So, I found out later that this incident had just happened maybe a half an hour earlier, before they received a 911 call from the male with the gunshot wound.

We had deputies who happened to be out in that area, so they got there fairly quickly. Every once in a while, you’re in the right place at the right time.

Yeardley: Right.

Greg: I got there, saw several emergency vehicles, police cars, parked at the bottom of this property. Now, this property leaves the roadway and goes uphill. It’s about five acres and it’s a steep uphill. There is several small outbuildings and shops dotted around it. And there’s one long paved driveway goes from the roadway all the way up to the top of the house. And the property is bordered by fencing, brush, trees, that sort of thing. This is out in the countryside area. I know that the action’s up at the top of the driveway. I saw that’s where a couple of the other detective vehicles were. So, I drive up there and met with my sergeant and another detective who’d already been there.

I found out that one of our partners had already been assigned to go to the hospital to meet with the male subject who’d been shot and try to get any information he could from him if he was able to speak.

Yeardley: I’m curious that the guy who was shot in the head is actually the one who called 911. So, at least at this point, anyway, not a fatal wound but getting shot in the head seems like a big deal.

Greg: Pretty serious.

Yeardley: I don’t know.

Greg: Yeah. [laughs] So, I got up there, there’s two deputies, and they’re holding a small infant about two months old. And as I get closer, I see this infant has blood speckled across his face and some staining on his little outfit. So, I don’t know quite where this baby fits into this picture yet, but I’m going to find out.

Yeardley: And the baby is alive?

Greg: Baby is alive. He’s alive. Well, crying. I speak with the deputy who was there with the baby, and I learned that upon receiving the phone call, when they get up the hill, they see a man come out of the house, basically in his underwear, holding a T-shirt to the side of his head. He’s bleeding profusely. He’s talking kind of slurring. They can’t understand because he’s also got a lot of blood coming out of his mouth. And so, he’s yelling for them to go into the house because his wife is shot. And he’s pretty insistent on that. They get in there and help him.

Yeardley: And this guy, the caller, what’s his name?

Greg: The caller is Steven. And this is a sad thing where you got to put your safety first before you can help somebody. Erring on the side of caution because they don’t have all the information just yet. So, we don’t know if this was a murder suicide gone wrong. We don’t know if it’s an ambush, if there’s a suspect still at large inside the house. So, the last thing we’re going to do is rush inside. So, after some quick negotiating, they’re telling Steven to come back to the car. They got an ambulance up there. They can see that he’s bleeding from a wound on the left side of his face, and it’s coming out of his mouth. They were able to get him into an ambulance right away.

They waited for another trooper to show up, and then they set about going in and clearing the house. And there’s nobody else in the house except for this man’s wife.

Yeardley: And what’s the woman’s name?

Greg: The woman’s name is Carrie. So, I go inside with my sergeant, and we just take a quick look inside the house to see what gear we’re going to need to bring with us inside. We entered through the garage into the home. It’s a really beautiful home. Very clean, very orderly. There’s a small room with a diaper bag, a car seat, right as soon as you enter. I had decided, let’s go in, try to get that diaper bag and take some quick photos of things, how they are at least in that area, and photograph the car seat and the diaper bag in place.

Then I had them take the diaper bag out and maybe look in the fridge, try to find some formula, some breast milk, whatever else we need to get for this baby, maybe a clean outfit. We didn’t know anything at all about this family at this time. We don’t know if there’s relatives nearby. So, we just called for child services to come take temporary custody of the baby, just to remove it from the scene. And while they work on finding out who a suitable person was that we could contact.

Yeardley: Do we have a name for the baby?

Greg: Ryan. So, I had been on scene for about 20 to 30 minutes. More cars were showing up down at the lower part of the driveway. And we hear a commotion. Some of the guys down below were yelling, turn to look downhill. And I see a lot of the other deputies running back towards about the midway point of this long, steep driveway. A couple of cars were repositioning along the side of the road of the driveway. And all of their attention was focused on a property or the fence line just to the east that bordered the driveway. I hear a lot of commands, yelling, pointing, and I gather that somebody had just manifested themselves in the bushes right nearby, right on the other side of the fence. So, I found out pretty quick that our police services lieutenant had just arrived on scene.

And as he just barely got out of his vehicle and started walking up the driveway, he notices a man jump up out of the bushes right on the other side of the fence, probably 15 yards away. So, very short distance. And this man’s got a black small handgun and he’s holding it to his own head. As we got closer, I heard them say, “Put the gun down, drop the gun. We’re going to be delivering gas.” I watched as a couple of deputies drove around to the adjoining property and started working their way through to where this subject was. They did deploy some gas, some pepper balls to the area.

Dave: To advance to where pepper balls are being deployed. That’s not step one. So, you have to be really noncompliant to arrive at that.

Greg: Yeah. And I heard some yelling coming from this person that they’re contacting. He was telling them to put their guns down and to leave, to go away. He made a comment about the aliens and if they don’t put their guns down, he’s going to shoot himself and then end the world or the aliens are going to come and end the world.

Dan: This is like an academy scenario.

Greg: About the best one they can come up with.

Dan: Yeah.

Yeardley: Like a police academy scenario.

Dan: Yeah. Where they just give you a problem that’s unsolvable.

Greg: Yeah.

Dave: Yeah. Like, hey, reason with this guy.

Dan: Yeah. They want to see how you react. And it’s basically to see how your mind works under pressure. Or if you get stuck in the goofy loop where you just keep repeating yourself like, “Show me your hands, show me your hands, show me your hands.” Like, can you pull yourself out of that situation and see it from a different angle? That’s a typical academy scenario.

Yeardley: Interesting. And about how old is this man in the bushes holding a gun to his head?

Greg: He’s mid-30s, early-40s, something like that.

Yeardley: Let’s give him a name already, even though you probably wouldn’t have known it at that moment.

Greg: His name is Shane.

Yeardley: Shane?

Greg: Yes.

Yeardley: Okay, so Shane is holding a gun to his head and telling the officers to put their guns down.

Greg: Yeah.

Dan: What’s Shane’s appearance? How does he look?

Greg: He’s dirty, ragged, wearing some really worn, dirty clothes. Eventually, they get him to comply. After some encouragement from some gas and some pepper ball rounds, they have him climb out of the bushes. He comes over the fence and he’s taken into custody. Deputies went back into the area where he had been holed up and found a small .380 semi-automatic subcompact handgun. While they’re patting Shane down for any more weapons, they find he’s got a carbon fiber Kydex-type holster with a clip on it in his back pocket. Coincidentally, about that time, we heard back from our partner who was at the hospital speaking with Steven. Steven wanted to let us know that at some point the previous evening, he had put his .380 semi-auto handgun either on the dining room table in his hat with his keys and wallet.

Yeardley: Is Steven in law enforcement or something? What sort of thing does he do that he carries a gun with him every day?

Greg: Well, he lives in this rural area. He does have a concealed handgun license. So, we find out that Steven said he didn’t remember seeing his weapon on his way out of the house. And he described it as a .380 handgun that he keeps in a carbon fiber Kydex holster with a clip on it.

Yeardley: There it is.

Greg: Now, this isn’t a coincidence of a whole other situation happening while we’re trying to do this other investigation. So, we’re pretty confident we have our suspect now who just introduced himself into the situation.

Yeardley: Right.

Greg: So, I was tasked with going back to the office to interview Shane and taking the lead on the investigation while the others continued to do the scene and start the canvassing of the rural neighborhoods, businesses, that sort of thing.

Dan: Greg, you’re about to interview the suspect, Shane, but before we get there, can you give us a sense of what actually happened at the house? Was Steven able to tell you anything while he was in the hospital?

Greg: Yeah, basically, Steven told the detective at the hospital he was just awakened by a loud shot, incredible pain in his head.

Dan: Nightmare scenario.

Greg: Yeah.

Dave: But Steven doesn’t describe seeing anyone that doesn’t belong in his house.

Greg: No, he didn’t. What he did say was that when he went out to meet with the deputies, he noticed a large blue blanket laying on the edge of his driveway. Steven had mentioned that’s not a blanket that belongs to his family or his house. Doesn’t know who it belonged to or how it got there.

[Break 1]

Dan: Got it. Okay, so back to your interview with Shane.

Greg: So, I go back to our office and set up our interview room. And we have Shane brought in. And like I said, Shane’s wearing these dirty olive gray sweatshirt, dirty pants. He’s been outside for quite a while.

Yeardley: So, are you thinking, Greg, that Shane is homeless?

Greg: Yes. He tells me this much. I advise him of his rights, tell him the room’s being recorded, that whole sort of thing. I asked, are you from around here? And Shane tells me he is from another state in the Midwest and that he just decided to go somewhere else. He heard the area that we live in was fairly lax with its drug laws, and that was a big appeal to him. So, he decided to come over our way. So, he tells me he had just arrived and was in the area. Had been sleeping on a bench down in the big city in our county. And at the time, there was a rather large homeless encampment that had sprouted up. And Shane decided he was just going to go exploring one day is what he says. So, he picks a direction and just starts off on foot.

Dan: I’m thinking about where he’s at because I’m familiar with that area. That’s a hell of a hike.

Greg: It is. It’s a long way for him to go. And so, we come immediately to, “Okay, so you’re walking out this way for no particular reason. How was it you came to be out in the bushes right next to a home that were all called to, that coincidentally, two people had been shot in there.” He had been acting pretty fidgety the entire time, shifting his seat, fiddling with his dirty fingers, looking around, rolling his eyes. So, I’m thinking he’s under the influence of something at this point.

Dave: What’s your suspicion?

Greg: Well, he told me he’s a big marijuana user. But I also noticed that it seemed to me that he was coming down from a little bit of a meth binge.

Dave: So, Shane’s using meth and marijuana?

Greg: Yeah. So, he basically tells me, I don’t know. I don’t remember. I said, “You don’t remember how you found yourself about 30 miles from where you woke up on a bench. Did you walk out there all at once just that morning?” Well, I left some time. He doesn’t quite remember when. Okay. “Where’d you find the gun that you were holding to your head?” “I don’t know. I don’t remember.” So, we’re going to play this game a little bit. Then he goes on to tell me that he’s hungry and tells me about the volunteer group that came out two days earlier and was providing food for the campers he was out there with and told me all the good food that they brought out.

And I stopped and says, you can remember what you had for breakfast two days ago, but you can’t tell me how you happened to come to be in the bushes next to a home where two people had been shot with a gun very similar to the one that you had, and you don’t remember where you found that gun? Shane tells me, “If you’re accusing me of being involved in a shooting or shooting somebody, then I better just talk to an attorney.” So, our interview was basically over at that point.

Yeardley: Interesting.

Dan: Shane’s got the awareness to lawyer up, but can’t remember how he got there.

Yeardley: Can’t remember how he got a gun and standing in the bushes, etc., etc.

Dave: You would be surprised at how many times handcuffs cause amnesia.

[laughter]

Yeardley: So Shane lawyers up.

Greg: So, Shane lawyers up, and so we’re done talking with him about this whole matter. And so, I tell him, “Okay, well, you’re going to be going to jail, and then you’re going to go to prison. And then if everything works out right, hopefully you go straight to hell after that.” So, he tells me, “I’ve actually got things to do, so how about you guys let me go and you can catch up to me in a couple of days?”

Yeardley: Oh, Shane.

Greg: And I’m thinking, what a piece of shit. I tell him, “No, in fact, you’re not going anywhere. Anywhere but jail, then to prison, and then, as I said before, straight to hell.”

[laughter]

Yeardley: He’s on his schedule, Greg.

Greg: He is.

Yeardley: Please don’t mess with Shane’s agenda.

Greg: Yes. So, I have Shane placed into our court transport holding area while I start working on search warrants, because I want to get a search warrant for his DNA, his blood, urine, all that sort of thing, so I can find out what chemicals he’s got on board. So, as I get the search warrant done for Shane’s blood, DNA, all that, we have the local medical unit that comes out to draw that blood, and I have transport deputies bring Shane out to a chair in the hallway where we can do this.

And I had learned from them that while he had been sitting inside his cell, after we had relieved him of his clothing for evidence and provided him with the jail clothes he was going to be wearing shortly anyways, he had tried to hang himself in his cell with his jail shirt.

Yeardley: Oh.

Greg: So, they caught onto that pretty quick and were able to intervene. So, Shane knows he’s got nothing to look forward to at this point. He knows he’s had– so he’s cooperative while we get all these samples from him. Then we have Shane transported and lodged in the jail. So, once I have his name, I want to dig into Shane’s story, see who he is, where he came from, how he came to be in our area since he’s not going to tell me himself. I find out that Shane actually did come from a Midwestern state. He traveled here by Greyhound. He gave me his real name which happens to be different from the one he gave to the other police agencies he had contact with during his travels down to our community.

Yeardley: Aha. Shane is Shane’s actual name.

Greg: Yes.

Yeardley: So, you happened to hit the jackpot there.

Greg: Yep. So, I find out that there’s a city about 40 minutes to the north of us. Officers there were called into a subject looking in vehicles and breaking into a few of them. Shane’s cited and released with a different name that he provides to them. Shane travels further down, winds up in our area where Shane does Shane things and starts stealing things from one of the small markets up there and causing a big scene. Deputies are called to deal with Shane at that time, he gives deputies there a different name so he’s lodged in jail that time for trespassing and theft of those items. So that’s his first lodging in our jail is under that name.

Yeardley: So, Shane gets around and it seems like he comes up with a new name every time he has a run in with the law.

Greg: Yeah.

Paul: Yeah. In fact, Yeardley, I oversaw what was our Central Identification Services which was part of forensic services for the sheriff’s office. And anybody that’s booked in the jail gets fingerprinted so they can give false ID. But because of the fingerprints that are rolled at the jail, now you can tie that person through fingerprints to other contacts to other times they’ve been fingerprinted even though they’ve been giving false IDs the entire time. And Greg, maybe your department had these, but you have these mobile fingerprint devices so patrol can actually get fingerprints at the contact before they’ve even taking him back to the jail. And so, now through wireless transmissions from these fingerprint devices, they can find out exactly who they are dealing with, even if the person produces a false ID.

Yeardley: It’s just getting harder and harder to be a good criminal. That’s what you’re saying, Paul, right?

[laughter]

Paul: We’re trying. [laughs]

Greg: Yeah.

Dan: Paul, it must be nice to have a budget where you can have mobile fingerprinting.

[laughter]

Dan: Yeah. we can’t have nice things like that.

Dave: That’s what I was thinking. I’m like, “Oh, this is the guy who has just the unlimited budget.” The rest of us are like, “Hey, can we. [Yeardley laughs] Can we buy like a dozen pens?” Not until the end of the fiscal year.

[laughter]

Yeardley: Oh, dear. Okay, so we’ve caught up with Shane and all of his stupid aliases.

Greg: Yeah. So, because these were relatively minor charges, the trespassing the theft of the smaller items, Shane is released the following morning. Shane walks to this big park encampment, decides to spend the day there, has his lovely breakfast provided by the volunteers who come out there before he decides to start off on his next adventure, which brings him out this way to where this home is and this incident.

Yeardley: So, Shane walked out of your jail the day before, he ends up in that field, and he’s wanted for murder at Steven and Carrie’s house?

Greg: Yes.

Yeardley: Oh, man.

Greg: Once I got Shane’s full name, I contacted a police agency in the area where Shane had come from up there, and I contacted his mother to try to find some information about him. I found out from the police agency that Shane had been arrested many times there for low level things. Outbursts, drug possession, thefts, lot of thefts.

Dave: Vagrancy type stuff.

Greg: That kind of thing.

Dave: Yeah.

Greg: He was also involved in a very dysfunctional relationship with a woman that often got violent. So, a lot of domestic abuse going on there. And in fact, his most recent arrest up there resulted from Shane holding his girlfriend hostage in her house and barricading himself inside with her with some knives.

Yeardley: Oh, God.

Dave: What was the resolution of that case or was it still pending? And that’s what prompted Shane to travel westward.

Greg: So, Shane was taken to jail there for that case. And it was during the COVID years. So, he got his stimulus check that the government had provided for him. He accessed that and was able to pay his own bail. That’s whenever he used his leftover cash to buy a Greyhound ticket and headed west.

Yeardley: Wow.

Dave: Those charges in his home state, the domestic violence, kidnapping, weapons, that’s prison stuff. You’re going to prison for that. And so that’s where I figured this was going, but it’s just frustrating.

Greg: Yeah.

Dave: Another preventable crime.

Greg: Exactly. So, as Shane is making his new trip out towards this incident, I find out that the city he had to walk through, where our county jail is located, took a report later that day after Shane got out of jail, of a subject who randomly knocked on a guy’s door who lives in the first home that was being built in this new community. And it’s Shane, by his description, and just asks for a cigarette and some water. And the guy tells him, “I don’t smoke, but I’ll give you some water.” It’s pretty hot out. It’s August. So, he provides Shane with a bottle of water. Watches him walk off behind some large equipment containers.

Its not, but a few minutes later, that resident smells smoke, looks out the window, and there’s a pretty good grass fire that’s just started right in the area where Shane had walked off to. So, the police met up with the resident. They got a good video from his house that shows Shane walking that way and then a short time later, running back the opposite way with the fire not far behind him.

Yeardley: What the hell?

Greg: Yeah.

Dan: He didn’t use the water to put the fire out.

Greg: No.

[laughter]

Dave: Missed opportunity.

Greg: Yeah.

Yeardley: Wow.

Greg: So, Shane’s such an asshole. He’s just making trouble everywhere he goes.

Yeardley: Jeez.

Greg: Shane works his way out to this other highway system that runs to the east up towards the mountains. And this is the area where this shooting had taken place, where Steve and Carrie live. So, on his way there, he has to pass another small convenience store between Steve and Carrie’s home and the convenience store, residents are driving to work about 4 in the morning, they’re heading east, and they pass Shane standing on the side of the roadway very near the driveway that leads up to Steve and Carrie’s house. And he’s leaning against the guardrail, has the same black bag, has the blue blanket hanging over his shoulder. He seemed to be just staring off into space as they drive by him. We contact a woman who lives a short ways away from Steve and Carrie’s home down a side street.

She says about 5 o’clock in the morning, she had just dozed off on the couch. Her husband works nights, so she just likes to get up early and wait for him to come home. Her dogs start going crazy. They’re barking and barking at the door. She bolts upright and she sees her doorknob moving. It’s turning a little bit. Luckily, her door was locked and the dogs didn’t seem to bother whoever was turning the knob on the outside. We believe it was Shane, but we don’t know because he’s right there in the same area.

Dave: More likely than not.

Greg: More likely than not.

Dave: It’s like a map quest of incrementally ending up at Steve and Carrie’s house. Shane’s just causing trouble. Everywhere Shane is, something bad happens.

Greg: Exactly.

[Break 2]

Greg: So, we put all those pieces together. We recovered the blanket. My partners were able to find the shopping bag that Shane had been carrying around. And it’s just full of random things, probably discarded items found along the roadway. Not much evidentiary value to any of the things that he had there related to our case.

Yeardley: But the blanket that Shane was carrying around is the same one Greg you find in the driveway.

Greg: It is.

Yeardley: When you guys arrive at Steve and Carrie’s, it’s like breadcrumbs. Like Dave was saying, “You know, on top of the MapQuest, here’s how Shane made his way to Steve and Carrie’s.” He also actually dropped things, literally.

Greg: Yes.

Dan: I’m impressed by Steve’s awareness to A, notice the blanket and say, “Hey, that doesn’t belong to my family.”

Greg: Yeah.

Dan: And then also Steven being aware that he didn’t see his gun.

Greg: Yes.

Dan: On the way out of the house, after all he’d just been through, Steven says, “Hey, I didn’t see my gun.”

Greg: Exactly. That was huge.

Dan: It’s pretty incredible.

Yeardley: Yeah.

Greg: So, now I get to speak with Steven. This is a few days later. He’s got some immediate treatment for his injuries. He’s staying with a friend who’s also taking care of Ryan for him while he’s healing. Steven and his wife have a big support system. They’re very well liked in their community. They own a small business that they both worked at. So, their employees are basically like their family and they have a large extended family anyways, so there was no shortage of people willing to take care of him and his son. So, I meet up with Steven at his friend’s house. He’s still pretty shaken up. He’s hard to talk with at first. He’s filled with anger. He’s filled with grief. And both emotions were competing with each other as we’re just trying to talk and get the story about what goes on.

As I was speaking with him, he had a large bandage on the left side of his face. He lost his left eye and his face was swollen from the trauma of the gunshot wound. So, he tells me about his life with his wife Carrie, how great it had been. They’d known each other for about seven years, been married for about four, I think. And they just recently had their two-month-old son and they were very much looking forward to having a good family life. They were living in their dream home that they had both worked hard for and purchased this property and had the house built. Everything was going great for Steven and Carrie. So, Steven tells me he goes to bed the night before.

He usually puts his keys, wallet in his hat on the dining room table so he can grab it the next morning, head out to work. He tells me he has a small handgun, the .380, and he thinks he put it in the hat on the table, or if he didn’t, then he put it on the nightstand. Those are the two places he normally puts it. And Steve tells me about 5 o’clock in the morning, maybe 6, he wakes up because the baby is crying. He changes the baby’s diaper and lets the dogs out. They’re antsy to go outside and go to the bathroom, so he opens a back door, lets the dogs out. They come back in and he just closes the door.

He goes back to bed because he doesn’t have to get up for work for about another hour and a half. But by then his wife is up and she decides to take the baby into the nursery room right across the hallway from their room to feed the baby. So, Steven says he goes back to sleep for a short time and then hears his dogs barking inside the house. And this was hard for him to talk about because his grief, his anger, and his feelings of guilt about this. He kept saying, “I should have got up and see what they were barking at. I thought they were barking at a deer, like outside, because it wouldn’t be uncommon to see deer.” So, he just kept sleeping for a little bit.

And he says all of a sudden, he hears the loudest noise and he has an intense hot flash of pain in his face. He didn’t know what was going on. He sat upright and just felt blood pouring out of his face, falling out of his mouth. He hears his wife say something like, “What the fuck?” And another loud blast. So, he gets up, he’s stumbling around. He comes out into the hallway to see his wife laying on the floor. Their baby’s trapped underneath it. She had fallen on top of it. So, what we find out through the scene and talking with Steven, Carrie’s in the room feeding Ryan. She hears the first gunshot and opens the door. While she’s holding the baby, we believe she sees the suspect, Shane, standing right there in the doorway.

She immediately shuts the door and Shane shoots through the door. She takes the hit just below the collarbone, punctures both lungs, part of the heart. So, she’s able to stumble out into the hallway, but she doesn’t make it past that before she collapses onto Ryan. Steven gets up, trying to see what’s happened, trying to talk to his wife. She’s not responding. He pulls the baby out from under her, sets it on the bed, looks for his phone. He gets it. He’s unable to make the phone call right away because the volume of blood pouring on the glass screen of his phone makes it hard to dial. So, he has to clean it off, hold it away a little bit. And he notices he has a hard time seeing.

Now he realizes his injuries are starting to set in at that point, so he’s able to call 911. And his voice is gurgled from the blood in his mouth. Police arrive. Dispatchers are telling him he needs to go outside. He’s telling them they need to come inside and take care of his wife. And that whole thing starts right there. He notices his back door is standing ajar, as is a sliding glass door next to it. And his wooden dowel that he keeps in the track, like an extra security measure has been pulled out and laid on the carpet next to it. He knows he didn’t open either of those doors, but he knew that he didn’t lock his door after he had let the dogs out either.

So, he exits out through the garage into the driveway, where he’s met by the deputies and then put in an ambulance and taken to the hospital. So, the detective that the scene doing the work finds a shell casing in the hallway, finds a shell casing underneath the bed, those were the only two shots that were fired. There was a bullet hole that went through the nursery door and small drops of blood on the inside. That’s where we come to believe that Carrie had shut the door and was leaning against it, doubled over a little bit as low, holding the door closed while she’s holding her baby. So, by a miracle, the bullet didn’t hit the baby that she was holding.

Dave: And that’s my takeaway, is blindly firing through a door on a woman who’s holding a baby. The wording in statutes manifesting extreme indifference to the value of human life. That’s what we’re talking about, like he just didn’t care. Evil shit.

Greg: Yes. Can’t emphasize what a big sack of shit Shane is. And again, my expressed desire that he goes straight to hell as soon as possible. So, Shane, for whatever reason, after his little petty crime spree leading out of town, comes up this road, for whatever reason, picks this particular property. We believe that he was in the bushes right outside the door and saw Steven open the door to let his dogs out and close the door. Shane decides to go let himself in the house. He finds the door unlocked. And if the gun was right there on the table with the hat and the keys and the wallet, Shane picks up the gun and basically goes hunting.

So instead of just taking the easy plunder, the wallet, the keys, the gun, and leaving, he makes the effort to go into the home and to see who’s there, where he finds Steven asleep on his side. The nursery door is closed. I don’t think Shane saw Carrie. Shane has the gun in his hand now, presses it to Steven’s temple while he’s sleeping and fires for no reason.

Yeardley: I was going to say, “What is that in need of? I mean, if you’re not going to just commit a robbery. And even if you are, nobody knows you’re there, presumably, yet. And so, fuck you, dude.

Dave: You got keys? I’m guessing there’s a car out there. Could have gotten away with a wallet, keys, and taken off with a new car, not be on foot, it’s like totally unnecessary.

Greg: Totally unnecessary. So that shows me his mindset that he makes that effort to go looking to see who’s in the home and where they are. I believe after Shane fired the round into Steven’s head he was startled by the appearance of Carrie in the doorway right across the hallway. She slams the door, and we believe he just fired straight into the door about where she was standing. Shane pulls open the sliding glass door, pulls out the wooden dowel, leaves it on the carpet, which we gather some fingerprints and DNA off of. And as the investigation goes on, these are items that we submitted to the crime lab. And of course, they come back with Shane’s DNA on that. So, we have the handgun that he took from the house, his fingerprints and DNA on the doors that he let himself into. This is pretty cut and dry.

Yeardley: It’s pretty good evidence.

Greg: It’s pretty good evidence.

Yeardley: Yeah.

Dave: Paul, you’re the encyclopedia of crazy weird shit happening. You’re a shit magnet yourself. Does this remind you of any cases or you’re also a good profiler. So, I’m wondering what your thoughts are on Shane.

Paul: I think, it goes down to Greg’s observation and law enforcement’s initial contacts with Shane. Shane presents himself, he’s holding a gun to his temple. But now he’s talking about aliens and having weird behaviors, it sounds like. So, I initially was thinking, okay, is he setting himself up for a mental defense or is he setting up a, let’s say a meth induced psychosis type of defense? However, him randomly walking around looking for unlocked doors, that immediately caused me to think of Richard Trenton, Chase out of Sacramento, the vampire killer. Now, this guy was truly psychotic. He literally was going through neighborhoods and the neighborhood the house that had the unlocked door, he went in and just butchered his victims. So, I’m kind of curious, Greg, you took Shane’s blood for tox work. What did he have in his system?

Greg: Marijuana and methamphetamine.

Paul: And then this goes to trial, I imagine.

Greg: I would imagine it was going to be going to trial. In the meantime, I had retired, so I knew that this was a case that was hanging out there that I would most likely have to come back and deal with in court. About a year after that, Shane decided to just change his plea and save everybody the hassle, probably at the strong advice of his attorney. So, I was given the date when Shane was going to change it to guilty. So, he was pleading to attempted murder, burglary in the first degree, and murder. So, I show up for court. Steven and his extended family are there. They want to see this happen. Shane changes his plea to guilty and opts for sentencing at the same time. That’s what they work out.

The judge offers Steven, anybody in his family the chance to speak to the court or to speak directly to Shane, and that’s exactly what they did. There’s about five or six family members, friends that approached and were full of anger. And they told Shane in no uncertain terms what he has done to Steven and Carrie and their son, what he’s done to their life, what he’s done to the business, what he’s done to their community, to their overall sense of security. And then it was Steven’s turn to speak. And it was just a lot of emotion.

Steven was talking about the life that Shane had just robbed him of, has robbed his son of his mother, of all the things that they had planned on doing as a family, how she was never going to get to see him grow up and accomplish all the things that Ryan was going to. It was pretty powerful. Shane wouldn’t turn around to look at him, didn’t say anything in his own defense. He just stared straight ahead. As the judge finished sentencing, the judge gave Shane 90 months for the attempted murder and burglary to be followed consecutively with a life sentence for murdering Carrie the minimum of which he has to do 30 years before he’s eligible for parole. But the judge didn’t believe Shane had a very good shot at getting parole at that point.

Yeardley: Mm-hmm.

Greg: Steven and his family were adamant with the judge that they would fight any efforts for Shane to be paroled.

Yeardley: Greg, were you able to learn anything from Shane’s mother when you actually contacted her?

Greg: I did. She told me that Shane was the middle of three sons that she had. As soon as he got into high school, he started smoking marijuana and shortly after that fell in with methamphetamines. Also dropped out of school and just worked a series of low level jobs for very short periods of time. As his meth use became more involved, she noticed his behaviors change. Shane started acting more erratic, more verbal outbursts and just general tweaker behavior. This prevented him from doing anything gainful. He mainly was homeless. He would stay with friends here and there, [unintelligible ] for a little bit.

If he had a girlfriend for a short period of time, he would live with them until he had this abusive relationship with his most recent girlfriend that led to him trapping her in her house while he was armed with knives. In that case, I know that the police were able to get the woman out through a window in a back room.

Dave: So that was truly going to be a prison case for him.

Greg: It was, but he had not been convicted of it yet.

Dave: Right. So, he absconds and it’s pending for him to get picked up on a warrant and sent back to the jurisdiction for trial.

Greg: It was, but curious thing was they did issue a warrant, but it was nonextraditable.

Dan: So, only in the state or surrounding counties or whatever.

Greg: Exactly. So, he had an nonextraditable warrant out of the state in the Midwest.

Dan: In your opinion, Greg, is this a symptom of what was going on during COVID.

Greg: It could have been also some things that these counties or jurisdictions take into account as their funding. Do they have the money to pay for an extradition? You know, to pay somebody to go either drive a van or fly cross country to go pick Shane up and bring them back once he left the state for another state. Maybe COVID restrictions didn’t want them coming back from one facility to another. Any number of reasons. But it was pretty sad that the first time he was contacted in the city to the north of us, if that warrant was extraditable, he would have been grabbed up right then and shipped back home.

Dave: I mean, Steven doesn’t give a shit about any of that. And I get it. Like, that’s frustrating for people when you’re like, now wait a minute. This could have all been prevented.

Greg: That’s his main complaint. I’ve spoken with Steven a number of times since this resolved. He’s doing really well. His son’s getting big. He’s back to work. He did lose his eye. And he’s still angry at the state in the Midwest. He’s angry at our department. He’s angry at the police up north. He knows it’s not really our fault. He believes we would have done everything we could have to head this off. But Shane was giving everybody a different name. He had not been convicted of the matter where he came from. He had used his government money to bail himself out of that situation. Shane went on this crime spree, and this happened. We are very lucky that he presented himself wherein he did, and we were able to apprehend him before he continued on to do something else.

[Break 3]

Dan: I’m under no illusion that Shane didn’t just try two doorknobs that night.

Greg: Yes.

Dan: He tried a lot. And he finally encountered one. The one that we talked about with the woman where her husband was working nights. She just happened to be there.

Greg: Yeah.

Dan: And saw it. And then obviously at Steven’s house, but there are other doorknobs.

Greg: There are so many homes and properties he walked by to get where he wound up at Steve and Carrie’s home. He had to have been trying doors as he’s picking up these various belongings along the way and stuffing him into a sack and throwing a blanket over his shoulder. Definitely fortunate that he didn’t cause harm to anybody else that night.

Dave: So, Paul, given the circumstances that the deputies show up after this 911 call, I’m just thinking back through all the phones that would be ringing. “Hey, we got a case. Let’s head out this way.” And they call up Paul and say, grab your van and all your cool equipment. How would you approach a rural property like this crime scene wise from photographs to, like you’re organizing the evidence collection, how do you work these scenes?

Paul: Well, anytime you’re going to respond out to a crime scene, particularly where you’ve got the homicide in our jurisdiction, we would go ahead and get the search warrant. So, there’s often a delay from our side from an evidence collection and documentation side to go inside the house. So, initially it is documenting the exterior, and looking for signs of ingress, signs of forced entry, documenting that, collecting that evidence. And this is where under this set of circumstances with Shane laying in the bushes with a gun. Now the crime scene investigators who are processing, waiting for the warrant to be signed, they’re out there and they’re exposed. But once the warrant is signed, now it is being able to get inside the house. And the priority at that point is going to be Carrie.

So, typically, how I would describe it is I carve my way through the house to get to the body. And so, I’m paying attention to evidence on my way where the body is at. I document that. I collect the fragile evidence that could potentially be lost as a result of movement to where the body is at. And so, once I’ve got all of that done, then I focus on the body. And it’s documenting the body, looking at the blood flows, looking at the blood patterns, collecting trace evidence, and then, of course, getting the death investigator out there. Once the death investigator gets out there, then I guide that death investigator back to the body so the rest of the crime scene is still maintained and the death investigator does their documentation.

And at this point, there may be situations where I have to interact with the body more intimately to get evidence. And so, I get permission from the death investigator in order to be able to do that. And once I am done completely with the body, then we get that body into the body bag, trying to limit any spurious blood patterns forming from blood dripping or anything like that. And then get the body out there, because we want that body in the morgue. We want them to be able to get that body at least refrigerated as fast as possible. And then now I can proceed with the documentation throughout the house.

Now we can get the latent print processing going, get the trajectory analysis going, recover the cartridge cases, try to recover a bullet if there’s an exit wound, let’s say on Carrie, or with Steven, and it sounds like with Steven, Greg, it appears that even though he received a gunshot wound to his temple, it did not enter into the brain. It probably went through his eye orbit and very possibly exited out his face into a pillow or into the mattress or something like that.

Greg: What we saw in the CT scan and what we believe really happened was the type of ammunition that was in the gun. It was designed for defense. It’s designed to expand, come apart, create a wide wound channel. And because we believe he pressed it to the bony part of Steven’s face, that stopped most of the expansion of the bullet, and it went in and downward into Steven’s mouth.

Paul: So, it didn’t exit?

Greg: No, there was a lot of fragments, but it did cause him to lose his left eye.

Paul: No, absolutely.

Dave: Greg had mentioned that there were some deputies working that day that were in the area, now where Dan and I worked in the area means within a minute or two, [laughs] you’re going to be on top of that house. The way Greg works in the area means it’s going to be several minutes. I try to put myself in Shane’s head hesitantly, but Shane’s clearly loitering around the property. And I just wonder if there’s some aspect of him being curious, wanting to watch. Kind of like a firebug watches an arson, that Shane wanted to watch the police response and see what he had created.

Yeardley: Right, Interesting.

Paul: And Dave, I had the thought when Greg was saying, that there were some deputies that were reasonably close to when the call came in that Shane was possibly leaving the location. And then all of a sudden, now law enforcement’s driving up. And I think the location of that blue blanket is what’s significant because that’s him of value to Shane. And it appears that he’s dropped it. And now he’s hiding and then has more and more law enforcement showing up. He’s going, “Oh, shit, they’re going to find me.” And so, he just decides to take the action into his own hands at that point.

Dave: Yeah.

Yeardley: That’s interesting.

Dan: Shane’s also thinking that Steven’s dead.

Paul: True.

Dan: So, Shane’s probably gob-smacked that the police are already showing up. I think that Shane thought he got away with it.

Paul: He got away clean.

Dan: And then all of a sudden you hear sirens and you’re like, “Oh, shit, I got to go to ground.”

Dave: Yes, absolutely. Like, what Paul’s saying is Shane got caught in the middle of his escape and oh, shit, I got to find a place to hide. Dive into it.

Yeardley: Right, that’s interesting.

Dan: Did Shane take anything else from the house other than the gun?

Greg: Nothing. Just the gun.

Dan: Not the wallet?

Greg: Not the wallet.

Dan: No other valuables?

Greg: Nothing.

Dan: He went in there to kill somebody.

Greg: He did.

Yeardley: Disgusting.

Dave: Paul’s given us so many cases and little anecdotes about the type of people that will do that. Shane wasn’t after property. Shane was after something else. And it’s just scary. Like there’s evil people just wandering onto your property in the middle of the summer.

Greg: They’re out there in this case in particular, of all the cases I’ve worked over the years, lots and lots of cases, all of them are different. There is a few threads of similarity running between some of them. But this case in particular has really stuck with me just because of the stranger factor. Somebody coming into your house through an unlocked door. As a result, I live in the middle of the city, but I am more vigilant about keeping our doors locked. I tell my kids, everybody, keep your doors locked. When I go out into my garage, every time I open the door, I’m half expecting to see somebody in the garage that doesn’t belong there. And so, I’m making a plan just to go out to the fridge in the garage to get another beer or whatever, if I open the door and there’s somebody standing there, what am I going to do?

Yeardley: Is that hyper vigilance more pronounced now that you’re all retired? Dan, Dave, Paul, Greg because also now you can’t be part of the remedy.

Dave: I think for me, it’s just I’m acutely aware of what’s out there and I’m not naive to it that there’s people out there that wouldn’t care if you’re begging for mercy, they would kill you and not give it a second thought. You’re just hyper aware that there’s bad people out there and bad things happen to really good people sometimes. Totally random.

Yeardley: Is it more so now?

Dave: Yes. [laughs] Yeah.

Greg: Once you start a career in law enforcement and look behind the curtain to see the people that actually live on our planet, that live in our communities, the people who, abuse drugs, abuse each other, abuse animals, do all these sorts of things. And like you just said, if they got no qualms about hurting you, the minute you choose to work in law enforcement, you forever forfeit the right to live in any degree of ignorance.

Yeardley: Right. What about you, Paul? You’re still sort of in it to help hopefully solve some cold cases.

Paul: I think like Greg said, you develop a hypervigilance just because you become aware of the evil that’s in the world. And I’m always blown away when I go to somebody’s residence. Oh, we don’t lock the doors. It’s very safe here where we live. And you know, I’m aware through all the cases what is out there. But at home we’re the same way. And we live what would be considered a relatively safe neighborhood. But that doesn’t mean bad things don’t happen in safe neighborhoods. Just like we saw with Steven and Carrie.

Yeardley: Right.

Dave: Dan?

Yeardley: Yeah, Dan.

Dan: I go back to when I was working, I used to clear my house.  Every time I came home, I would open every room and clear my house. You mentioned the garage. Two nights ago, I opened the garage and I’m like, what if somebody was standing in the middle of my garage looking at me like, what’s about to happen? And am I mentally prepared for it? Because it’s going to happen quickly. These are all the things, you know, we all talk about it. Once you’re made aware of what’s out there, you can’t be naive to it anymore. It’s over.

Dave: My takeaway for this case, Steven, I can’t put myself in those shoes, like, to lose everything that’s important to you and totally random. I just feel bad for the family.

Yeardley: Yeah.

Dave: It’s horrible.

Yeardley: It’s horrible.

Dan: The thing that I take away from this is the position of Ryan when Carrie goes down, Steven survives his gunshot. I think Steven saved Ryan’s life because Ryan would have been smothered.

Greg: He would have been, yeah.

Yeardley: Because his mom was on top of him.

Dan: Yes. Steven saved Ryan’s life.

Greg: Absolutely. After he was picked up by Child Services, a family member was contacted fairly quickly. Ryan was taken in for an exam at the hospital. And I believe they found he had a small fracture in one of his vertebrae from the impact of his mother collapsing on top of him. But yes, very likely, if he had lain there any longer, if Steven’s injury had been worse, where he couldn’t get out of bed to go look and see what had happened, it very likely would have been very bad for Ryan.

Yeardley: You potentially lose all three of those family members.

Greg: Yes.

Yeardley: Ugh. And then lastly, I was thinking, Greg, what you said about the Midwestern state who had this nonextraditable warrant out for Shane, whatever the reasons were, it seems to me there should be a kind of yes, but if it’s a violent crime of this sort that would actually result in prison, that’s not part of this policy.

Greg: That was one of the real big sticking points with Steven in this aftermath. He’s angry at that state and he’s looking into possibly who he would talk to about changing a law to make that happen. So, that when somebody walks away from a serious crime like that, we got to do everything we can to get him back to where he belongs to answer for those charges so that he can’t continue to go on and do the things that he did.

Yeardley: Exactly. And also, the woman who was being held hostage with Shane and his knives, I mean, she too must feel like, “Well, shit, I didn’t get my day in court either.” Thank you so much for bringing this to us today, Greg, it’s just lovely to see you.

Greg: You too. Thanks for having me back.

Dan: Nice work, Greg. I remember when this case happened and our community’s small enough where when I saw the name of the victims and I saw their photos and social media, we have mutual friends and seeing the impact that Steven and Carrie had on the community with the mutual friends that I had, it’s just a tragedy.

Greg: It is.

Dan: Steven is well respected in our community and so is Carrie, and it’s just awful.

Greg: Yes.

Dave: Nice work, Greg. Not surprised that you guys put the case together as quickly and completely as you guys did.

Greg: Thank you.

Paul: Yeah, Great job, Greg.

[music]

Yeardley: Small Town Dicks was created by Detectives Dan and Dave. The podcast is produced by Jessica Halstead and me, Yeardley Smith. Our senior editor is Soren Begin and our editors are Christina Bracamontes and Erin Huntley. The dynamic duo who does our social media is Monika Scott and Andrew Polk.

Our associate producers are the Real Nick Smitty and Erin Gaynor. Logan Heftel is our production manager. Our books are cooked and cats wrangled by Ben Cornwell. It would make our day if you became a member of our Small Town Fam by following us on Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube at @smalltowndicks, we love hearing from you.

Oh, our groovy theme song was composed by John Forrest. Also, if you’d like to support the making of this podcast, go to smalltowndicks.com/superfam and hit that little join button. There, for a small subscription fee, you’ll find exclusive content you can’t get anywhere else.

The transcripts of this podcast are thanks to SpeechDocs and they can be found on our website, smalltowndicks.com. Thank you SpeechDocs for this wonderful service. Small Town Dicks is an Audio 99 Production. Small Town Fam, thanks for listening. Nobody is better than you.

[Transcript provided by SpeechDocs Podcast Transcription]